Anachronism Discussion: Why Does the United States Still Have the Death Penalty?

The Last Public Execution, in Owensboro, Kentucky, in 1936, Witnessed by Over 20,000 Voyeurs

Why the U.S. still has capital punishment is a core question seldom asked.  The United States remains one of the few developed nations that still enforces the death penalty. While most Western democracies have abolished capital punishment, the U.S. continues to practice it, albeit with declining frequency. This persistence is due to a combination of historical, political, and cultural factors and the decentralized nature of the American legal system.
​
Historical and Cultural Legacy

The death penalty has deep historical roots in the U.S., tracing back to English common law. Colonial America widely adopted capital punishment for crimes ranging from murder to theft. The practice remained ingrained in American jurisprudence even as European nations gradually abolished it. Unlike many developed countries that underwent radical legal reforms in response to human rights concerns, the U.S. has held onto many aspects of its early legal traditions, including capital punishment.

Additionally, American culture tends to emphasize retribution in justice. The idea of "an eye for an eye" resonates with many citizens, who see the death penalty as a just response to heinous crimes. Unlike some European nations, where rehabilitation is the primary goal of criminal justice, the U.S. often leans toward punitive measures. This cultural perspective helps sustain support for the death penalty, particularly in some areas of the country.

State Autonomy and Legal Decentralization

One of the main reasons the death penalty persists in the U.S. is the decentralized legal system. Unlike many other developed nations, which have unified national laws, the U.S. allows each state to determine its policies regarding capital punishment. Currently, 27 states still allow the death penalty, though some have not carried out executions in years.

This state autonomy creates a patchwork of laws, with some states, particularly in the South, continuing to carry out executions. In contrast, others, like those in the Northeast and West Coast, have abolished or placed moratoriums on capital punishment. The federal government also retains the death penalty, though it is rarely used.

Political Considerations

The death penalty remains a highly politicized issue in the U.S. Politicians often use it to appeal to their voter base, particularly in conservative-leaning states where law-and-order policies are popular. Tough-on-crime rhetoric has historically been a winning political strategy, and advocating for the death penalty signals a firm stance against violent criminals.

Even as opposition to the death penalty grows, repealing it remains challenging due to the political risks involved. Politicians fear being labeled as "soft on crime," which can be damaging in elections. While some states have abolished the death penalty through legislative action, many others still rely on voter referendums, where public opinion continues to favor capital punishment in certain regions.

Public Opinion and Perception of Justice

Though support for the death penalty has declined over the years, a significant portion of Americans still believe it is necessary. Many view it as a deterrent against violent crime, even though studies suggest it has little impact on crime rates. Additionally, some argue that certain crimes are so egregious that execution is the only fitting punishment.

However, concerns about wrongful convictions, racial disparities, and the high costs associated with capital punishment have led to growing calls for reform. DNA evidence has exonerated numerous death row inmates, raising serious doubts about the system’s infallibility. These factors have contributed to a gradual decline in executions and an increase in life sentences without parole as an alternative.

Conclusion

The U.S. continues to practice the death penalty due to a combination of historical precedent, state autonomy, political factors, and public opinion. While the trend is shifting away from capital punishment, it remains entrenched in many states. Until the political landscape changes significantly and public opposition reaches a tipping point, the U.S. will likely remain an outlier among developed nations in maintaining the death penalty.