Blood, Blues, and the Battle for the Soul: Sinners as a Neo-Expressionist Allegory of Power

Ryan Coogler's Sinners (2025) is a bold cinematic vision that merges Southern Gothic horror with rich allegorical storytelling, crafting a film that operates as a supernatural thriller and a searing critique of cultural appropriation, systemic power, and spiritual resistance. Set in 1932 Mississippi, the film tells the story of twin brothers Smoke and Stack (both played with haunting duality by Michael B. Jordan) who return home to open a juke joint—a place of joy, music, and Black autonomy. But what begins as an effort to reclaim space quickly spirals into a confrontation with the literal and symbolic forces of vampirism, exploitation, and spiritual corruption.

At the heart of Sinners is an unmistakable neo-expressionist aesthetic. The film distorts reality through expressionistic lighting, eerie set design, and supernatural overtones. These stylistic choices aren't just for show but amplify the psychological and cultural anxieties that are simmering beneath the surface. Everything in the film, from the sweat-soaked juke joint to the blood-soaked bayous, pulses with symbolic meaning. In this way, Sinners follows the neo-expressionist cinema tradition, where emotion and metaphor matter more than realism.

The vampire antagonist, Remmick, portrayed with chilling magnetism by Cillian Murphy, isn't merely a creature of the night; he's a metaphor for white cultural appropriation. His obsession with Sammie, the cousins' blues-singing nephew whose music channels ancestral power, is framed not as admiration but as exploitation. Remmick offers Sammie immortality, an escape from racism, in exchange for his soul and song. The offer echoes the historic theft of Black art and labor under the guise of inclusion, raising urgent questions about what assimilation costs those forced to survive under hegemonic structures.

The juke joint, a recurring set piece throughout the film, becomes a spiritual battleground. It's a sacred space where music, culture, and communion resist the erasure of Black identity. When Grace, a central character whose child is held hostage by the vampires, is coerced into inviting them inside, it serves as a tragic metaphor for how Black cultural spaces can be infiltrated under duress, compromise, or economic desperation. This gesture, simple in action, reverberates with historical weight.

The music itself is wielded as a weapon and a shield in Sinners. Sammie's blues performances aren't entertainment but ritual, resistance, and resurrection. His music doesn't just move the living; it calls upon the dead, channeling African spiritual traditions and challenging the sterile order of Western religion. Through these performances, Coogler articulates the film's underlying message: culture is power, and when preserved authentically, it can push back against even the most insidious forces.

Economic ambition, too, is explored with complexity. Smoke and Stack's venture is not just about profit but sovereignty. However, even their self-made success exposes them to new vulnerabilities; their business becomes a target for supernatural and societal predators. Sinners subtly critique the notion that wealth can shield the marginalized from exploitation. Economic power remains fragile, corruptible, and unsatisfying without cultural and spiritual integrity.

By adopting a neo-expressionist approach, Coogler ensures that Sinners doesn't just tell a story; it evokes one. Every frame is emotionally charged, every performance symbolic, and every plot turn weighted with allegorical resonance. The distortion of reality serves not to confuse but to clarify—to reveal the psychological and systemic violence that realism too often obscures.

Sinners is not just a horror film or a commentary on race, class, and culture; it's a mythic exploration of external and internal control. It dares to ask what happens when the oppressed are offered power, but only on the terms of the oppressor. It forces viewers to grapple with the seductive nature of compromise and the cost of survival when the price is identity.
​
In its visual language, thematic ambition, and spiritual depth, Sinners joins the lineage of neo-expressionist masterpieces. It is operatic in emotion, supernatural in form, and yet terrifyingly grounded in truth. It's not just about blood; it's about what's buried deep beneath it.