Busted Bubbles: Debunking the Most Common Myths About Diet Soda

Despite their widespread popularity, diet sodas are shrouded in controversy. From claims that they cause cancer to fears that they're worse for your waistline than regular soda, these artificially sweetened beverages have become the subject of persistent urban myths. But how much of this is rooted in fact, and how much is just fizzy fiction? Let's explore some of the most common myths about diet soda and what the science says.

Myth 1: Diet Soda Causes Cancer

The Claim: Artificial sweeteners like aspartame, used in diet sodas, cause cancer.

The Science: This fear largely stems from a 1970s study in which lab rats given massive doses of saccharin developed bladder cancer. However, subsequent research—including large-scale epidemiological studies—has not found any definitive link between aspartame or other FDA-approved artificial sweeteners and cancer in humans.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), and the World Health Organization (WHO) have all reviewed the data and concluded that aspartame is safe for human consumption within established daily intake levels. For example, a 2023 review in Critical Reviews in Toxicology reaffirmed aspartame's safety when consumed within the acceptable daily intake (50 mg per kg of body weight in the U.S.). A 70 kg (154 lb) person would need to drink about 19 cans of diet soda in one day to reach the U.S. ADI for aspartame.​

Myth 2: Diet Soda Makes You Gain Weight

The Claim: Drinking diet soda leads to weight gain, not loss because it confuses your metabolism or increases cravings.

The Science: This myth is based on observational studies that found a correlation between diet soda consumption and higher body mass index (BMI). But correlation isn't causation. People who are already overweight may choose diet soda to cut calories—meaning diet soda isn't causing weight gain but is chosen because of it.

More rigorous randomized controlled trials (RCTs) suggest the opposite: diet sodas can be helpful for weight management. A 2014 study published in Obesity found that overweight participants who drank diet soda lost more weight over 12 weeks than those who drank only water. The key lies in overall dietary patterns. If a diet soda replaces a 150-calorie sugary beverage, that's a net reduction in energy intake.

Myth 3: Artificial Sweeteners Spike Blood Sugar

The Claim: Artificial sweeteners disrupt glucose metabolism and may increase the risk of type 2 diabetes.

The Science: Again, science says it is not so fast. Aspartame, sucralose, and acesulfame potassium do not contain carbohydrates and don't raise blood sugar levels. Multiple studies have found that these sweeteners are safe for people with diabetes when consumed in moderation.

Some research has suggested that certain sweeteners may slightly alter gut microbiota, which, in theory, could impact insulin sensitivity. However, these findings are preliminary and based on animal models or studies using quantities far beyond typical consumption. A 2020 meta-analysis in Advances in Nutrition concluded that low- and no-calorie sweeteners have no significant effect on human blood glucose or insulin levels.

Myth 4: Diet Soda Is Addictive Like Drugs

The Claim: Diet soda creates addiction-like behavior, mainly because of its sweet taste and caffeine content.

The Science: While diet soda often contains caffeine, the levels are usually lower than those in coffee or energy drinks. The sweetness itself doesn't create a chemical addiction. However, people may develop habitual behaviors around drinking soda—especially if it's part of their daily routine or used as a pick-me-up.

​This is more of a psychological dependency than a physical addiction. Unlike substances such as nicotine or opioids, artificial sweeteners do not stimulate the brain's reward centers in a way that leads to withdrawal or physical dependency. A 2015 paper in Frontiers in Psychiatry concluded that while "sugar addiction" is a popular notion, it lacks the physiological withdrawal symptoms typical of clinically recognized addictions.

Myth 5: Diet Soda Erodes Bones and Causes Osteoporosis

The Claim: Diet soda's acidity and artificial ingredients leach calcium from bones.

The Science: This myth is likely tied to the effects of phosphoric acid, an ingredient in many colas. Some studies have found a weak association between cola intake and lower bone mineral density in women, but these effects were not consistently found in diet soda or men. Moreover, the observed impact may be due to calcium displacement. People who drink more soda may drink less milk or calcium-fortified juice.

A 2020 study in Osteoporosis International found no strong link between diet soda and bone fractures or osteoporosis when calcium and vitamin D intake were adequate.

Bottom Line: Moderation, Not Mythology

Diet soda is not a magic health elixir, but it's not the villain it's often made out to be. Anecdotes, misinterpreted studies, or outdated science fuel most fears surrounding diet soda. Reputable health agencies worldwide continue to affirm the safety of approved artificial sweeteners.
​
If you enjoy diet soda as part of a balanced diet, there's little reason to feel guilty about it. Just as with any food or beverage, moderation is key. It's far more essential to look at your overall nutrition and lifestyle than to single out one drink as the culprit or cure.