Ireland vs. the UK Post-Brexit: the Dramatic Costs of Nativism

Since Brexit officially took effect in 2020, the economic trajectories of Ireland and the United Kingdom (UK) have diverged notably. While both nations have faced challenges adjusting to new trade realities, Ireland has leveraged its position within the European Union (EU) to attract business and investment. In contrast, the UK has encountered a sluggish growth trajectory amid trade barriers and economic uncertainties.

GDP and Economic Growth

In the years following Brexit, Ireland has consistently outperformed the UK regarding economic growth. According to the Central Statistics Office (CSO) of Ireland, the country's Gross Domestic Product (GDP) grew by approximately 12% in 2022, driven by substantial foreign direct investment (FDI) and exports from multinational corporations, particularly in pharmaceuticals and technology. In contrast, the UK's Office for National Statistics (ONS) reported GDP growth of only 4.1% in 2022, with a slowdown in 2023 due to inflation and sluggish trade activity.

This disparity is further reflected in GDP per capita figures. As of 2023, Ireland's GDP per capita stood at approximately $106,997, significantly higher than the UK's $55,203. This substantial difference underscores Ireland's robust economic performance in the post-Brexit era.

Trade and Investment

Brexit introduced trade barriers that have significantly impacted the UK economy, particularly in sectors reliant on exports. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) estimates that Brexit has resulted in a 4% reduction in UK productivity, with trade volumes declining. Ireland, however, has seen an increase in exports, especially to the EU and US markets.

Ireland's trade surplus has continued to grow, supported by its thriving pharmaceutical, medical devices, and tech industries. The UK, however, has faced a decline in trade with the EU, leading many businesses to set up additional operations in Ireland to bypass border issues. Dublin has become an attractive location for financial services firms looking for EU access, with numerous banks and asset management firms shifting operations from London.

Employment and Wages

Ireland's labor market has remained resilient post-Brexit, with an unemployment rate of 4.2% as of late 2023, compared to the UK's 4.9%. Wage growth in Ireland has been more substantial, fueled by the influx of high-paying jobs in tech and finance. The UK, meanwhile, has faced labor shortages in sectors like agriculture, hospitality, and health services, exacerbated by the reduction in EU workers post-Brexit.

Inflation and Cost of Living

Ireland and the UK have faced inflationary pressures, but the UK has struggled more significantly with rising costs. UK inflation peaked at 11.1% in late 2022, driven by energy price shocks and supply chain disruptions. In contrast, Ireland's inflation rate was 8.2% at its peak. The higher cost of living in the UK has put pressure on households, with food and energy bills surging.

The Cost of Nativism and Brexit

One of the most significant economic consequences of Brexit has been the cost of nativism. A key motivation behind Brexit was the desire to reduce immigration and reclaim national sovereignty. However, this policy shift has come with steep economic consequences. The departure of EU workers has led to severe labor shortages in critical sectors such as healthcare, construction, and hospitality. Businesses reliant on migrant labor have struggled to fill vacancies, leading to rising costs and reduced productivity.

Moreover, the UK's departure from the EU single market has complicated trade, increasing costs for businesses and consumers. Many firms that once relied on frictionless trade with Europe have relocated or expanded operations elsewhere, with Ireland emerging as a key beneficiary. The push for economic independence has paradoxically resulted in economic isolation and stagnation, reinforcing the challenges of a post-Brexit Britain.

Implications for Northern Ireland and Potential Reunification

The economic divergence between Ireland and the UK has also reignited discussions around the potential reunification of Northern Ireland with the Republic of Ireland. Northern Ireland remains part of the UK but has retained access to the EU single market under the post-Brexit trade arrangements. However, economic benefits from full EU membership, as enjoyed by Ireland, may make reunification more appealing.

Higher GDP per capita, more substantial wage growth, and a more resilient trade environment in Ireland contrast with economic stagnation in the UK, leading some in Northern Ireland to reconsider their financial future. Business leaders and policymakers have raised concerns over trade frictions between Northern Ireland and Great Britain. At the same time, the Republic of Ireland continues to enjoy unfettered access to the EU market. If economic trends continue along these lines, the argument for reunification could gain more traction, driven by political and cultural considerations and economic pragmatism.

Conclusion
​
Post-Brexit, Ireland has leveraged its EU membership to strengthen its economy, while the UK has encountered multiple economic hurdles. While both economies face challenges, Ireland's strong trade relationships and investment inflows suggest a more promising outlook than the UK's slower growth and trade difficulties. For Northern Ireland, economic comparisons with the Republic of Ireland could further influence discussions on reunification as the appeal of a more stable and prosperous economy becomes increasingly evident.