Maine's Viking Penny Mystery: A Tale of History and Intrigue

In the rugged landscape of Maine, a tantalizing archaeological mystery has captured the imagination of historians, archaeologists, and enthusiasts for decades: the so-called "Viking penny." This enigmatic artifact—a small silver coin of Norwegian origin dating back to the 11th century—was discovered in 1957 and has since been the subject of intense debate and speculation. Is it evidence of pre-Columbian Norse exploration in the Americas, or does its presence in Maine tell a different story?

Discovery and Context

The Viking penny was unearthed at the Goddard Site, an ancient Native American settlement in Brooklin, Maine. The excavation was conducted by local amateur archaeologist Guy Mellgren, who discovered the coin among thousands of other artifacts, including pottery shards, stone tools, and trade goods. The site, believed to have been occupied between 1180 and 1235 CE, was a bustling hub of Native American trade.

What makes the Viking penny particularly intriguing is its origin. The coin was identified as a 12th-century Norwegian silver penny minted during the reign of King Olaf Kyrre (1067–1093). Its presence in a Native American settlement in Maine has sparked numerous theories about its journey.

Theories Behind the Coin's Presence

The most thrilling theory posits that the penny is direct evidence of Norse exploration in North America. The Viking sagas tell of Norse expeditions to a land called Vinland, widely believed to be part of modern-day Canada. Norse settlements, like the one at L'Anse aux Meadows in Newfoundland, confirm that Vikings reached North America around 1000 CE. However, no conclusive evidence suggests they ventured as far south as Maine.

Another plausible explanation is that the coin arrived through trade networks. The Native Americans of the Goddard Site were part of extensive trading systems that spanned the continent. Artifacts from distant regions, such as copper from the Great Lakes and shells from the Gulf of Mexico, have been found at similar sites. It's possible the penny changed hands multiple times before arriving in Maine.

Some skeptics argue the coin may be a modern intrusion, accidentally introduced during the excavation or by earlier collectors. While this theory casts doubt on its authenticity as an ancient artifact, it does not explain the coin's genuine medieval origins.

Implications and Debate

If the Viking penny is authentic and contemporaneous with the Goddard Site, it would provide compelling evidence of the interconnectedness of early peoples and hint at indirect contact between Native Americans and Norse explorers. However, the lack of additional Norse artifacts at the site has left many scholars cautious. The coin remains an isolated find; without corroborating evidence, it is difficult to draw definitive conclusions.

Conclusion
​
The Viking penny of Maine is a fascinating artifact that continues to spark debate and wonder. Whether it represents a direct link to Norse explorers or a testament to the vast trade networks of pre-Columbian America, its story invites us to reconsider the complexity of human history. For now, the penny remains a tantalizing clue, a reminder that history often holds more questions than answers.