The Brutalist: A Multi-Layered Discussion of the Immigrant Experience in America

Brady Corbet's "The Brutalist" is a monumental cinematic endeavor that delves deep into the intricate tapestry of post-World War II America, exploring the multifaceted social and economic challenges immigrants face. The film chronicles the life of László Tóth, a Hungarian-Jewish architect portrayed by Adrien Brody, as he navigates the turbulent waters of the American Dream. The film's screen time is over three and a half hours, full of wide-shot visuals in the Christopher Nolan tradition.

Immigrant Experience and Assimilation

Upon arriving in the United States, László is immediately confronted with the harsh realities of immigrant life. His initial residence with his cousin Attila in Philadelphia is a microcosm of the broader societal pressures to assimilate. Having shed his Jewish identity to blend into American society, Attila epitomizes the sacrifices many immigrants make to gain acceptance. This internalized pressure to conform often leads to a loss of cultural identity, as seen in Attila's transformation and his strained relationship with László. The film poignantly captures the dichotomy between preserving one's heritage and the desire to fit into a new cultural landscape.

Economic Exploitation and Class Disparities

László's journey is fraught with economic hardships that underscore the systemic exploitation of immigrants. His collaboration with the affluent industrialist Harrison Lee Van Buren, portrayed by Guy Pearce, highlights the power imbalances inherent in capitalist societies. Van Buren's commissioning of László to design a grand community center initially appears benevolent. Still, it gradually reveals itself as a manifestation of vanity and control. The project symbolizes how the wealthy elite often manipulates artistic and cultural endeavors for personal glorification, sidelining the genuine contributions of immigrant talents. This dynamic reflects broader societal patterns where the labor and creativity of marginalized groups are commodified, with profits and recognition disproportionately accruing to those in positions of power.

Racism and Xenophobia

Throughout the narrative, László encounters overt and covert forms of racism and xenophobia. From derogatory remarks to systemic barriers, the film sheds light on the prejudices that pervade American society. These experiences are not isolated incidents but are indicative of a broader societal reluctance to embrace diversity. The film critiques this hypocrisy, highlighting how America, a nation built by immigrants, often marginalizes those very contributors. This paradox is poignantly captured in scenes where László's innovative designs are celebrated. Yet, he remains an outsider, constantly reminded of his "otherness."

Artistic Integrity vs. Capitalist Demands

A central theme in "The Brutalist" is the tension between artistic integrity and capitalist imperatives. László's architectural vision, rooted in the Brutalist movement's emphasis on raw materials and functional design, clashes with Van Buren's commercial interests. This conflict underscores the broader societal struggle where art is often subsumed under market demands, erasing creative authenticity. László's battles to preserve his design principles amidst mounting pressure to conform serve as a testament to the resilience of true artistry in the face of commodification.

Trauma and Resilience

The lingering effects of war and displacement are palpable throughout László's journey. His personal struggles with addiction and the challenges faced by his family, particularly his wife Erzsébet and niece Zsófia, reflect the deep-seated trauma experienced by many post-war immigrants. Yet, amidst these challenges, the film also celebrates resilience. László's unwavering commitment to his craft and his family's determination to rebuild their lives epitomize the indomitable spirit of those who strive to carve out a place in a new world despite being scarred by history.

Conclusion
​
"The Brutalist" is a profound exploration of the immigrant experience, delving into the complexities of assimilation, economic exploitation, systemic prejudice, and the preservation of artistic integrity. Through László Tóth's journey, the film offers a poignant commentary on the societal structures that both invite and impede the progress of those seeking a better life. It is a stark reminder of immigrants' multifaceted challenges and the enduring strength required to navigate and overcome them.