The Great McDonald's Monopoly Scam: How Jerome Jacobson Rigged the Game

​During the late 1980s and 1990s, McDonald's Monopoly game was a cultural phenomenon. Millions of Americans eagerly collected game pieces, hoping to win cash prizes and luxury items. Few knew that the game was manipulated by an elaborate criminal conspiracy that would eventually become one of fast food's most audacious fraud schemes.

At the center of this scandal was Jerome Jacobson, a former police officer who worked as a security chief for Simon Marketing, the company responsible for producing and distributing McDonald's Monopoly game pieces. Jacobson discovered and exploited a critical vulnerability in the game's security system with remarkable cunning.

His method was surprisingly simple yet effective. As head of security, Jacobson had access to the specially printed game pieces before they were distributed. He began stealing rare winning pieces—those promising large cash prizes and luxury items like cars and vacations—and selling them to a network of co-conspirators.

Jacobson would carefully remove the rare pieces from their protective packaging and replace them with non-winning pieces. He then distributed the stolen pieces to a carefully cultivated network of friends, family members, and criminal associates who would claim the prizes. To avoid suspicion, these confederates came from diverse backgrounds and locations across the United States.

The scope of the fraud was staggering. Between 1989 and 2001, Jacobson and his associates claimed over $24 million in fraudulent prizes. Some of the most significant wins included a $1 million prize claimed by a family in St. Louis and a $25,000 prize won by another accomplice.

The scheme might have continued indefinitely without an anonymous tip to the FBI in 2000. Special Agent Richard Dent led an extensive investigation that unraveled the entire operation. In 2001, Jacobson and several of his co-conspirators were arrested and charged with multiple felonies.

The legal consequences were severe. Jacobson was sentenced to 37 months in federal prison and ordered to pay significant restitution. His co-conspirators received similar punishments, effectively dismantling the fraud network.

McDonald's and Simon Marketing were left embarrassed by the massive security breach. The incident led to substantial changes in managing instant-win contests, with companies implementing more rigorous security protocols to prevent similar fraud.

The McDonald's Monopoly scam became a cautionary tale about the vulnerabilities in corporate promotional systems and the potential for insider fraud. It demonstrated how a single individual with suitable access and motivation could exploit what was supposed to be a fun, fair game for personal gain.
​
Today, the story fascinates people, a remarkable example of an elaborate white-collar crime that remained undetected for over a decade.