The Know Nothing Party: America's Anti-Immigrant Political Movement of the 1850s with Eerie Similarities to the Present

​In the tumultuous decade preceding the American Civil War, a nativist and anti-immigrant political movement swept across the United States, briefly capturing the nation's attention and reshaping its political landscape. This movement coalesced into the Know Nothing Party, officially known as the American Party, which rose to prominence in the mid-1850s before rapidly declining by the end of the decade. The Know Nothings, as they were colloquially known, left an indelible mark on American political history and highlighted the deep-seated anxieties about immigration and cultural change that continue to resonate in American politics today.

The Flag of the Know Nothing Party

The roots of the Know Nothing movement can be traced to the 1840s, a period of significant demographic change in the United States. A massive wave of immigration, primarily from Ireland and Germany, brought millions of newcomers to American shores. This influx was driven by factors such as the Irish Potato Famine and European political upheaval, notably the failed revolutions in 1848.

As these immigrants, many of them Catholic, settled in American cities, they sparked concern among some native-born Protestant Americans. These nativists feared that the newcomers would change the character of American society, compete for jobs, and potentially shift the balance of political power. They were particularly wary of the Catholic Church, which they viewed as a foreign, authoritarian institution at odds with American democratic values.
​
It was in this context of cultural anxiety and economic uncertainty that secret nativist societies began to form. The Order of the Star Spangled Banner was the most prominent, founded in New York in 1849. Members of these societies were instructed to reply "I know nothing" when asked about their activities, hence the moniker "Know Nothings."

A Rendition of the Mythical Citizen Know Nothing

The Know Nothing movement gained significant traction in the early 1850s, capitalizing on the political vacuum created by the declining Whig Party and the controversy surrounding the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854. As the movement grew, it transformed from a loose network of secret societies into a formal political party, adopting the name "American Party" in 1855.

The Know Nothings' platform centered on nativism, anti-Catholicism, and temperance. They advocated for stricter immigration laws, a 21-year naturalization period for immigrants, and laws barring foreign-born citizens from holding public office. They also called for the reading of the Protestant Bible in public schools and restrictions on alcohol sales.

The party's appeal extended beyond its core nativist ideology. It positioned itself as an anti-establishment force, capitalizing on widespread disillusionment with the existing two-party system. The Know Nothings also attracted supporters by promising to combat political corruption and advocating for widespread reforms.
​
At its peak in 1854-1855, the Know Nothing movement achieved significant electoral success. They won control of the Massachusetts state legislature, elected governors in several states, and sent over 40 representatives to Congress. In 1856, they even fielded a presidential candidate, former President Millard Fillmore, who ran on the American Party ticket and secured 21.5% of the popular vote.

Anti-Catholic Know Nothing Propaganda

Despite its rapid rise, the Know Nothing Party's prominence was short-lived. Several factors contributed to its equally swift decline:

• Internal divisions: The party struggled to maintain unity, particularly over the issue of slavery. Northern and Southern factions found it increasingly difficult to reconcile their differences on this contentious topic.
• Rise of the Republican Party: The newly formed Republican Party, with its focus on opposing the expansion of slavery, began to attract many Northern Know Nothings who prioritized this issue over nativism.
• Changing political landscape: As the sectional crisis over slavery intensified in the late 1850s, it overshadowed other political issues, including immigration.
• Contradictions in ideology: The party's anti-immigrant stance conflicted with America's self-image as a nation of immigrants, making it challenging to sustain broad support.

 
By 1860, the Know Nothing Party had effectively ceased to exist as a national political force. Many of its Northern supporters had migrated to the Republican Party. At the same time, its Southern wing had primarily been absorbed by the Constitutional Union Party.

Although short-lived, the Know Nothing movement left a lasting impact on American politics and society. It highlighted the enduring tensions surrounding immigration and assimilation in American culture. The movement's rhetoric and policies foreshadowed later nativist movements, such as the Immigration Restriction League of the late 19th century and the Ku Klux Klan revival in the 1920s.

The Know Nothings also contributed to the realignment of the American party system in the 1850s, playing a role in the collapse of the Second Party System and the emergence of the Republican Party. Their brief success demonstrated the potential appeal of nativist and populist messages in American politics, resurfacing periodically throughout U.S. history.
​
Moreover, the Know Nothing movement spurred a backlash that ultimately strengthened the position of immigrants in American society. Many immigrant communities, particularly Irish Catholics, became more politically organized in response to Know Nothing hostility. This political mobilization laid the groundwork for the critical role that immigrant votes would play in urban politics in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

Depiction of a Know Nothing Party Rally

The legacy of the Know Nothings can also be seen in ongoing debates about American identity, immigration policy, and the place of religion in public life. While the explicit nativism and anti-Catholicism of the Know Nothings are now widely rejected, questions about assimilation, cultural change, and the impact of immigration continue to be hotly debated in American politics.

The Know Nothing Party represents a significant, if brief, chapter in American political history. Its rapid rise and fall in the 1850s encapsulate a period of intense social and political upheaval in the antebellum United States. While the party quickly faded from the scene, the anxieties it tapped into and the issues it raised have continued to resonate in American politics.

The story of the Know Nothings serves as a reminder of the complex and often contentious nature of American identity. It illustrates how periods of significant demographic change can spark political movements that seek to define and defend a particular vision of national character. At the same time, the ultimate failure of the Know Nothings points to the resilience of America's immigrant tradition and the ongoing process of negotiating and renegotiating what it means to be American.
​
As the United States continues to grapple with issues of immigration, cultural diversity, and national identity in the 21st century, the history of the Know Nothing Party offers valuable insights into the historical roots of these debates and the challenges of balancing unity and diversity in a pluralistic society.