The Suspension of Disbelief in Romantic Relationships: Why It Happens and the Hidden Hazards

In fiction, the "suspension of disbelief" refers to a reader's willingness to accept implausible premises to engage emotionally. But this exact psychological mechanism often appears in romantic relationships, only the stakes are far more personal and potentially damaging. When individuals overlook glaring red flags, explain away troubling behavior, or idealize partners far beyond reason, they may be engaging in a form of emotional self-deception that mirrors how audiences accept dragons in fantasy novels or time travel in movies.

Why does this happen? At its core, suspension of disbelief in relationships is driven by a mixture of emotional vulnerability, hope, and cognitive bias. New love triggers a robust neurochemical response; dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin flood the brain, creating feelings of euphoria, attachment, and trust. In this state, critical thinking is often subdued. People may ignore or minimize contradictions between a partner's actions and their stated intentions, choosing instead to believe in a romanticized version of the relationship.

Additionally, psychological needs, such as the desire for security, companionship, or validation, can incentivize self-deception. For some, believing that a partner is "the one" offers not only emotional comfort but also a sense of narrative coherence: a life story in which everything finally makes sense. This creates a selective perception where positive signs are amplified and negative ones dismissed. It's not so much that people don't see the warning signs; it's that they reinterpret them to fit a desired storyline.

These mental gymnastics, however, come at a cost.

The hazards of suspending disbelief in relationships are numerous and often painful. One significant risk is staying too long in unhealthy or abusive dynamics. People who minimize emotional manipulation, infidelity, or dishonesty may end up compromising their well-being to preserve the illusion of love. What begins as a hopeful interpretation quickly becomes a psychological trap, where each new disappointment is rationalized instead of addressed.

Another danger lies in the erosion of self-trust. When individuals continually ignore their instincts to preserve a fantasy, they begin to lose confidence in their judgment. This can lead to codependency, chronic anxiety, and difficulty setting boundaries, not just in romantic relationships but across many aspects of life.

Moreover, the longer disbelief is sustained, the more devastating the eventual reckoning can be. When reality finally breaks through, it's not just the relationship that collapses; it's the entire narrative that sustains it. The emotional fallout can include feelings of shame, betrayal, and existential confusion.

Breaking free from this pattern requires cultivating self-awareness and emotional honesty. Friends and therapists can play a crucial role by offering objective perspectives and asking the hard questions that partners may be avoiding. Recognizing the difference between love and illusion isn't always easy. Still, it's essential for building relationships founded on mutual respect and truth.
​
Ultimately, romantic love is at its best when it invites us to dream without asking us to deny what we know to be true.