Understanding Learned Helplessness: A Barrier to Growth and a Tool for Manipulation

​Learned helplessness is a psychological phenomenon where individuals believe they have no control over their circumstances, leading them to give up on trying to change or escape undesirable situations. This concept, first identified by psychologists Martin Seligman and Steven Maier in the 1960s, has profound implications for mental health, education, relationships, and workplace dynamics. However, while often unintentional, some individuals may leverage their perceived helplessness to influence or manipulate others.

Origins and Mechanisms

The term "learned helplessness" emerged from experiments involving animals. Seligman and Maier conducted studies where dogs were subjected to inescapable electric shocks. When later allowed to escape, the dogs made no effort, having "learned" their actions were futile. This lack of response, even when escape became possible, highlighted a fundamental psychological shift: a belief in the inability to influence outcomes, even when circumstances changed.

Learned helplessness manifests in similar ways in humans. Individuals exposed to repeated failures or uncontrollable stressors may internalize a sense of powerlessness. Over time, they may stop trying to change their situation, even when opportunities for improvement exist. This pattern is typical in contexts such as chronic poverty, abusive relationships, or long-term unemployment.

Psychological and Emotional Impacts

Learned helplessness is closely linked to depression and anxiety. When people feel they lack control over their lives, they are more likely to experience feelings of worthlessness, hopelessness, and despair. This can create a vicious cycle: believing their inability to affect change leads to passivity, perpetuating unfavorable circumstances and reinforcing the original sense of helplessness.

In educational settings, students who repeatedly struggle with certain subjects may develop learned helplessness, believing they are inherently incapable of success. This can erode motivation and hinder academic performance. Similarly, employees facing unrelenting criticism or insurmountable challenges may disengage in workplaces, reducing productivity and innovation.

Helplessness as a Tool for Manipulation

In some cases, individuals who experience or display learned helplessness may use it—consciously or unconsciously—to influence others. This behavior often stems from needing support, attention, or control. For example:

1. Eliciting Sympathy: A person may adopt a helpless person to gain sympathy from others. They may draw emotional support, resources, or special treatment from well-meaning individuals by highlighting their struggles and perceived inability to change.
2. Avoiding Responsibility: Helplessness can be used as a shield to avoid accountability. For instance, employees might claim they are "bad at technology" to evade specific tasks, placing the burden on coworkers instead.
3. Exerting Control: Ironically, learned helplessness can become a subtle form of control. By projecting an image of vulnerability, individuals may coerce others into acting on their behalf, effectively managing situations without direct effort.

While these behaviors may offer short-term benefits, they can damage relationships and perpetuate unhealthy dynamics, fostering resentment in those manipulated.

Breaking the Cycle and Addressing Manipulation

The good news is that learned helplessness is not a permanent state. Recognizing its presence and underlying motives is the first step toward change. Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is a proven approach to addressing learned helplessness, helping individuals challenge distorted beliefs and adopt more proactive behaviors.

Setting clear boundaries is essential for those affected by manipulation stemming from helplessness. Offering support without enabling passive behaviors can encourage individuals to take ownership of their actions. For instance, instead of solving problems for someone, guide them in finding their solutions.

Conclusion
​
Learned helplessness is a complex phenomenon with both personal and relational consequences. While many struggle with genuine feelings of powerlessness, others may unconsciously use these behaviors to influence those around them. We can empower individuals to move beyond helplessness and build healthier, more balanced relationships by fostering self-awareness, resilience, and mutual accountability.