U.S. Military Desertion from 1860 to Today: A History of Soldiers Who Walked Away

Military desertion has existed as long as armed conflict itself. From the battlefields of the Civil War to the deserts of Iraq and mountains of Afghanistan, American soldiers have chosen to walk away from duty for reasons that range from fear and fatigue to protest and disillusionment. Each era has faced its own crisis of morale, and every conflict has tested the U.S. military's handling of loyalty, discipline, and punishment.

This article traces the history of desertion in the U.S. military from 1860 to the present. It explores how rates shifted, what drove soldiers to desert, and how military authorities responded over time.

Civil War Chaos: When Loyalty Collapsed

The Civil War introduced a massive conscripted force into a bitterly divided nation. That combination produced a historic wave of desertions. More than 200,000 Union soldiers deserted during the conflict. Confederate armies, while smaller in number, likely experienced even higher rates. Some historians estimate that 10 to 15 percent of Confederate soldiers abandoned their posts before the war ended.

Soldiers left for many reasons. Some fled from fear. Others had no food, no shoes, and no hope. In places like Kentucky and Tennessee, divided loyalties blurred the line between desertion and survival. A man might return home rather than shoot at his cousin.

Military justice operated inconsistently. Courts-martial issued sentences for imprisonment or hard labor. Though commanders threatened death by firing squad, they rarely carried out executions. President Abraham Lincoln often reduced those sentences, believing that mercy would do more to hold the Army together than bloodshed.

The Indian Wars: Misery and Isolation on the Frontier

After 1865, the U.S. Army turned westward. The Indian Wars offered few moments of glory. Soldiers stationed at dusty outposts across the Great Plains faced long periods of boredom, extreme weather conditions, inadequate rations, and limited contact with home. These grim conditions prompted many to abandon their posts.

By the 1870s, the annual desertion rate climbed to nearly 30 percent. Many of the deserters had recently immigrated to the U.S. and felt little allegiance to the Army. Others chose to take their chances outside the fence, looking for steady work or a quieter life.

Army commanders imposed strict punishments. Soldiers caught deserting received dishonorable discharges, lost their pay, and sometimes spent months or years in labor camps. Some wore shame uniforms or marched with signs identifying them as deserters. Though physical punishments such as whipping had been banned, the military still relied on public humiliation and hard labor to send a message.

World War I: Loyalty Meets Bureaucracy

During World War I, the U.S. military expanded rapidly, bringing millions of young men into uniform. Although most served without incident, about 21,000 soldiers received convictions for desertion during the brief but intense period of American involvement from 1917 to 1919.

In this war, desertion rarely stemmed from outright rebellion. Most deserters disappeared temporarily. Some lost their units in the chaos of deployment, while others broke under the stress of trench warfare. The military responded with formal procedures, handing out sentences that included hard labor, pay forfeiture, and dishonorable discharges.

While commanders requested the death penalty in hundreds of cases, no American soldier faced execution for desertion during World War I. Military leaders relied on institutional discipline, not firing squads, to maintain order.

World War II: One Soldier Faces the Ultimate Penalty

World War II demanded an enormous military effort. Over 16 million Americans served, and the war enjoyed strong public support. Still, more than 50,000 soldiers deserted between 1941 and 1945.

The reasons reflected the scope and strain of the conflict. Combat fatigue, emotional trauma, long deployments, and fear all played a role. Most deserters returned to civilian life quietly. Some wandered away from units and reappeared after days or weeks.

Military authorities handed down thousands of sentences, but only one soldier, Private Eddie Slovik, paid with his life. Slovik refused to return to combat after leaving his unit in France. When he refused to recant, a military court sentenced him to death. He faced execution by firing squad in January 1945, becoming the only American executed for desertion since the Civil War. His case still sparks debate over whether the Army intended to make an example out of him.

Vietnam: Protest, Politics, and the Draft

The Vietnam War produced the most significant wave of desertion in modern U.S. history. Between 1965 and 1973, more than 500,000 service members deserted. Many felt little connection to the war's aims. Some objected to the draft. Others outright opposed U.S. military policy in Southeast Asia.

Deserters left bases across the U.S. and abroad. Thousands fled to Canada, Sweden, or underground networks that helped them evade arrest. Some became public voices against the war, writing memoirs or speaking out at protests. Others simply vanished.

The military treated desertion during Vietnam unevenly. Some deserters received administrative discharges with no prison time. Others spent months or years behind bars. In the war's aftermath, President Gerald Ford offered conditional clemency in 1974. President Jimmy Carter followed with a full pardon for draft evaders and some deserters in 1977. The legacy of desertion during Vietnam reshaped how Americans view military dissent.

Iraq and Afghanistan: A Quieter Crisis

Following the military's elimination of the draft in 1973, the all-volunteer force attracted a more professional and motivated group of service members. That shift led to a sharp drop in desertion. Still, the long wars in Iraq and Afghanistan pushed some soldiers to the edge.

Between 2001 and 2007, more than 25,000 service members deserted. Many had already completed multiple deployments. Some struggled with PTSD. Others questioned why the wars dragged on with no clear end. These desertions rarely made headlines, and the military often handled them quietly.

Punishments varied. Soldiers who returned voluntarily might receive administrative separation. Those who refused to return or spoke out publicly could face court-martial and confinement. A few high-profile cases, such as Army Specialist André Shepherd, who sought asylum in Germany, drew international attention and renewed questions about the balance between obedience and conscience.

Desertion in the Modern Military

Desertion remains a crime under the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Article 85 defines it clearly, and soldiers who walk away without intent to return can still face imprisonment and dishonorable discharge. In theory, military courts can impose the death penalty during wartime. Still, no U.S. court has done so since World War II.

Today's military focuses more on prevention than punishment. Commanders work to spot burnout early. Support teams address mental health, family stress, and morale. Even so, some service members reach a point where they walk away.

The reasons have not changed much in 160 years. Soldiers still desert when they feel fear, fatigue, alienation, or moral conflict. The numbers may fall, but the reality persists. Desertion tells a deeper story about the human limits of war and the burden the military places on those who serve.

Conclusion: The Long Shadow of Desertion

American military history cannot be told honestly without facing the stories of those who left the fight. Desertion reveals more than weakness; it reveals stress fractures in the system, failures of leadership, gaps in support, wars that outlast the reasons for fighting them.
​
From the mud of Petersburg to the streets of Baghdad, desertion has tested how far the military can stretch its people before they break. It reminds us that patriotism, loyalty, and sacrifice don't come automatically with a uniform. Sometimes, walking away becomes the final act of judgment in a war no longer worth fighting.